Build My BizDeck
Verified head-to-head comparison

BrightPay vs Sage Payroll

Compare suitability, cost model, commitment, eligibility, capabilities and limitations using the same verified product data.

Provider 1

BrightPay

Employers wanting dedicated payroll software

Cloud pricing via employer/employee calculator

Read the full review →
Provider 2

Sage Payroll

Businesses already using Sage or wanting established payroll software

From £12/month + VAT

Read the full review →
ComparisonBrightPaySage Payroll
Best forEmployers wanting dedicated payroll softwareBusinesses already using Sage or wanting established payroll software
CostCloud pricing via employer/employee calculatorFrom £12/month + VAT
Pricing basispayroll subscriptionmonthly payroll subscription
CommitmentSubscription; cloud productMonthly subscription
EligibilityAvailable to relevant UK business customers subject to the provider’s current eligibility and product terms.Available to relevant UK business customers subject to the provider’s current eligibility and product terms.
Key capabilitiesPayroll processing · RTI workflows · Auto-enrolment support · Employee portal optionsPayroll processing · RTI workflows · Pension support · Sage integrations
Reasons to considerPayroll-focused product · Strong fit for businesses wanting dedicated payrollEstablished UK payroll product · Natural fit with some Sage stacks
Things to checkHR functionality may require separate tools · Cloud and desktop options should be comparedCompare plan and deployment model · HR needs may sit elsewhere
Verified2026-09-022026-09-02

See every Payroll & HR option

Compare the wider catalogue using the same verified fields.

Compare all products →